Acknowledgments xi Introduction xiii Walter Sinnott-Armstrong Moral Intuition = Fast and Frugal Heuristics? 1(46) Gerd Gigerenzer Fast, Frugal, and (Sometimes) Wrong 27(4) Cass R. Sunstein Moral Heuristics and Consequentialism 31(10) Julia Driver Don Loeb Reply to Comments 41(6) Gerd Gigerenzer Framing Moral Intuitions 47(60) Walter Sinnott-Armstrong Moral Intuitions Framed 77(6) William Tolhurst Defending Ethical Intuitionism 83(14) Russ Shafer-Landau How to Apply Generalities: Reply to Tolhurst and Shafer-Landau 97(10) Walter Sinnott-Armstrong Reviving Rawls's Linguistic Analogy: Operative Principles and the Causal Structure of Moral Actions 107(74) Marc D. Hauser Liane Young Fiery Cushman Reviving Rawls's Linguistic Analogy Inside and Out 145(12) Ron Mallon Resisting the Linguistic Analogy: A Commentary on Hauser, Young, and Cushman 157(14) Jesse J. Prinz On Misreading the Linguistic Analogy: Response to Jesse Prinz and Ron Mallon 171(10) Marc D. Hauser Liane Young Fiery Cushman Social Intuitionists Answer Six Questions about Moral Psychology 181(74) Jonathan Haidt Fredrik Bjorklund Does Social Intuitionism Flatter Morality or Challenge It? 219(14) Daniel Jacobson The Social Intuitionist Model: Some Counter-Intuitions 233(8) Darcia Narvaez Social Intuitionists Reason, in Conversation 241(14) Jonathan Haidt Frederick Bjorklund Sentimentalism Naturalized 255(48) Shaun Nichols Normative Theory or Theory of Mind? A Response to Nichols 275(4) James Blair Sentimental Rules and Moral Disagreement: Comment on Nichols 279(12) Justin D'Arms Sentiment, Intention, and Disagreement: Replies to Blair and D'Arms 291(12) Shaun Nichols How to Argue about Disagreement: Evaluative Diversity and Moral Realism 303(52) John M. Doris Alexandra Plakias Against Convergent Moral Realism: The Respective Roles of Philosophical Argument and Empirical Evidence 333(6) Brian Leiter Disagreement about Disagreement 339(6) Paul Bloomfield How to Find a Disagreement: Philosophical Diversity and Moral Realism 345(10) Alexandra Plakias John M. Doris Moral Incoherentism: How to Pull a Metaphysical Rabbit out of a Semantic Hat 355(68) Don Loeb Metaethical Variability, Incoherence, and Error 387(16) Michael B. Gill Moral Semantics and Empirical Inquiry 403(10) Geoffrey Sayre-McCord Reply to Gill and Sayre-McCord 413(10) Don Loeb Attributions of Causation and Moral Responsibility 423(40) Julia Driver Causal Judgment and Moral Judgment: Two Experiments 441(8) Joshua Knobe Ben Fraser Can You Be Morally Responsible for Someone's Death If Nothing You Did Caused It? 449(10) John Deigh Kinds of Norms and Legal Causation: Reply to Knobe and Fraser and Deigh 459(4) Julia Driver References 463(36) Contributors 499(2) Index to Volume 1 501(28) Index to Volume 2 529(30) Index to Volume 3 559